Nicola Chatham v. Her Majestys Advocate

At the appeal the court heard arguments on three grounds out of nine. (4) That there was insufficient evidence in law of the appellant having taken part in a concerted attack (1) that the trial judge failed to give adequate directions to the jury in respect of the various statements attributed to the jury and that (6)esto ground 4 was rejected the trial judge failed to give adequate directions to the jury in relation to the evidence on the basis of which concert might be proved.